Tea Party Winners: Debra E. Marvin's winner is: Kathleen, Jennifer Hudson Taylor's winner of her MacGregor Legacy series is Chris Granville and second winner is Britney Adams for the plaque and For Love or Country novel:, Angela K. Couch's winner is: , Carrie Fancett Pagels's winner per random.org is Beverly Duell-Moore for a copy of BCB and second winner for colonial goodies is: Carrie Moore Gould, Denise Weimer's winner: Janet Marie Dowell, Shannon McNear's winner is: Adriann Harris, Pegg Thomas's winner is: Susan C

Wednesday, May 21, 2014

Review of SO FAIR A LADY

I'm so honored to be back on Colonial Quills today and I'm even MORE honored to be able to share with you a wonderful review of SO FAIR A LADY by the magnificent Rachel McMillain. Rachel is a fabulous writer, and on her blog A Fair Substitute for Heaven she wrote a beautiful review of my debut novel, and was gracious enough to allow me to share it with you today.

Take it away, Rachel!

"Boston, MA 1773: Shards of Eliza Campbell's life crash to the ground when she discovers a devastating secret: her father was a spy for the Sons of Liberty. Determined to uncover the truth, not even a marriage proposal from the dashing British Officer Samuel Martin can dissuade her. When rescued from British capture by handsome patriot Thomas Watson, Eliza discovers what her father risked his life for and yearns to know more. But will her budding attraction to this courageous patriot damage her already wounded heart? 

After years of being blackmailed by Officer Martin, Thomas plans to start a new life in the small town of Sandwich. However, when his actions place Eliza and her sister in danger, he must act quickly to protect them from falling into enemy hands. If the three of them are discovered, their lives will never be the same. Now, not only must he protect Eliza, he must protect his heart from a love that is sure to wound him far greater than any British soldier ever could.

Know what is funny? I have been reading Christian historicals forever and 99 per cent of them are by American authors and so few of them are set during the Revolutionary War. This has always baffled me. People, if you’ve got it, flaunt it! This is a fascinating period of history and I have always enjoyed the surmounting tension that cracks an inevitable rift which births the American nation. Amber Lynn Perry also loves this period to distraction as is evident in her pitch-perfect historical romance So Fair a Lady.

I confess I am not one to read independently-published fiction: mainly because I am always a little skeptical about its editing. Fortunately for me, and for you, prospective reader, Perry is a professional. There is nothing in this book that would lead anyone to believe its publication was one sought independently by its author. Indeed, the prose is so crystalline and scintillating, the characterization so well-rounded and the pacing so perfect, it is a far stronger offering than many books of similar ilk who have their home in mainstream publishing. Also, can we say cover love?

There are several historical romance tropes that are followed here: the spunky heroine who must feign a marriage of circumstance while falling for the unlikeliest of heroes as the proper old suitor is revealed to have off-colour circumstance; family circumstances ( in this case, secret Patriotism, traitorism! spies!) are exhumed and the heroine must re-discover her identity against the pitfalls of a long-buried familial ideology while the hero picks up the ramifications of this fall-out in stride; two people who fight their attraction for each other, often jumping hurdles of mis-understanding that ruffle their journey toward their deserved happy end.

In Perry’s capable hand, these conventions are sought in unique light.  She knows the genre well and she imparts into the traditional her own strengths such as the characterization mentioned, some surprisingly beautiful prose and a strong sense of historical fact.

At one point, our hero Thomas ( he of the printing press—sigh! ) must see our heroine Eliza ( wrought with gumption) and her believable younger sister to safety in Sandwich, Mass.  Their moonlit-canopied adventure, met with danger and unpredictable elements was presented with perfect exposition making it one of my favourite sequences in CBA historicals this year.

There is a strong and encouraging faith element made more potent when explored in conjunction with a tenuous time in history where everyone was acting on conscience and principle. Perry does well at making the motives of both sides understandable and human.

I was surprised and delighted to discover an exciting new voice in CBA historical fiction."

Thank you so much, Rachel!!

Rachel McMillan lives in Toronto and reads a lot of books and watches a lot of baseball. Her bookish ramblings are housed on blogspot at A Fair Substitute For Heaven. Find her on Twitter: @rachkmc

Amber Lynn Perry is a historical romance novelist, focusing on her favorite time in American history--the Revolutionary era. She currently lives in Washington state with her husband and two daughters. Amber loves to hear from readers and you can contact her through her website, www.amberlynnperry.com or through her Facebook page, www.facebook.com/authoramberlynnperry


  1. Great review RACHEL of an outstanding book I have had the pleasure of reading!! Thank you AMBER for the hard work I know went into writing So Fair a Lady.

    1. Teresa, thank you so much for stopping by! I was very honored by this review and I'm just thrilled to know you enjoyed it as well!! That's wonderful!

  2. Great review. I have not read anything by Amber before but this sounds like one I would enjoy.
    Blessings, Tina

    1. Hi TIna! If you like colonial I think you would love this story. If you read it let me know what you think! HUGS!

  3. It was an absolute pleasure to read and review So Fair a Lady! Amber is such an exciting new voice in the market AND I so enjoy this time period :)

  4. Great review. This is a promising book and author.

  5. Loved this review! So Fair a Lady is my next read, and I can't wait! Now if only work didn't get in the way of my reading time so I could get to it sooner! ;)

    Thank you Rachel for your beautiful review, and thank you, Amber for your dedication to the craft if writing!


Thanks for commenting, please check back for our replies!